The Best Tomato Pie Recipe

1. What is Southern Tomato Pie
2. How to Make Southern Tomato Pie
3. Why This Recipe Stands Out
4. Ingredients Needed for Southern Tomato Pie
5. Tips for Serving and Storing Southern Tomato Pie
6. Frequently Asked Questions
7. Wrapping It Up: Why Tomato Pie Is True Southern Gold

I’ll be honest, Southern tomato pie easy as it sounds, kinda baffled me the first time I came across it. I mean, pie… with tomatoes? Isn’t that usually for apples or whatever? But oh boy, after my neighbor brought one over for a summer barbecue, my mind changed. If you’re sitting there scratching your head about what to do with late summer tomatoes, this recipe is better than a lemonade on a hot afternoon. Seriously. It’s crispy, cheesy, and pretty much the flavor of the South in one crusty bite.

 

What is Southern Tomato Pie

Okay, so let’s clear this up in plain English – Southern tomato pie is like the hidden gem of Southern kitchens. It started out back in the day when folks needed ways to use up piles of ripe tomatoes. But unlike cold pizza or a tomato tart, this is real-deal, savory comfort food. Imagine thick slices of fresh tomato, hugged with gooey cheese (cheddar’s the hero), a kiss of mayo, and all tucked into a golden pie crust. Some folks say it’s sorta like a quiche and pizza had a Southern baby, with more twang.

The classic version uses good old ingredients, nothing hard to pronounce, and you’ll see it pop up at potlucks, family gatherings—honestly, I’ve even seen it at some weddings down here. If you’ve never tried it, trust me, your tastebuds are about to do a little jig.

How to Make Southern Tomato Pie

Want the real deal? Here goes. First step: slice up your tomatoes, but pat them dry or you’ll have a soggy mess (learned that the hard way). I like to sprinkle a little salt on them too, just to dunk out even more liquid.

Next, toss together some shredded cheddar with mayo, salt, pepper, and a dash of hot sauce if you fancy a kick. Pre-bake the crust for a few minutes, so it holds up. Then you layer the tomatoes and mozzarella (if you want to get extra cheesy), then finish with that mayo-cheese magic. Into the oven it goes, until bubbly and a little brown on top. Don’t even think about slicing it hot—let it cool. Trust me, or you’ll burn your mouth like I once did at Thanksgiving.

It’s not rocket science, but a little patience goes a long way. Sometimes I throw in some fresh basil or chopped green onions for good measure too.

“I was nervous the first time I tried tomato pie, but this recipe made it so simple and honestly delicious! The crust was never soggy and my family inhaled the whole thing.” — Jenny K., North Carolina

 

Why This Recipe Stands Out

Here’s the thing—everyone’s got their “secret twist.” But for me, it’s the freshness of those tomatoes that makes it a five-star restaurant on your own porch. Using really fresh, in-season tomatoes is key. It takes the simple stuff and makes it taste special. And honestly, that cheddar-mayo topping? Pure love. It’s rich without taking itself too seriously.

You don’t need fancy ingredients, or a whole afternoon free, either. Some tomato pies end up watery or bland, which is just a travesty. This method keeps things rich, tangy, and that little hint of crispy cheddar on top? Heavenly. Your friends will think you stole the recipe from someone’s grandma.

 

Ingredients Needed for Southern Tomato Pie

So here’s your short shopping list—don’t overthink it. Grab:

1. A frozen or homemade pie crust (just do yourself a favor and use one)
2. Three good-sized ripe tomatoes (go for beefsteak or whatever looks best)
3. One to one-and-a-half cups of grated sharp cheddar (seriously go sharp)
4. Half a cup of Duke’s Mayo (or Hellmann’s, no judgment)
5. One egg (helps keep things together)
6. Salt and lots of ground black pepper
7. Optional: a sprinkle of fresh basil, a handful of mozzarella, or some sliced green onions

That’s it. Nothing tricky or fancy. Just regular grocery store stuff that shines when put together right.

Tips for Serving and Storing Southern Tomato Pie

Honestly, by the time it’s cooled, folks start circling the kitchen like hungry mosquitoes. But let it sit a bit! Here’s the best way to serve and keep it fresh:

1. Serve warm, not piping hot (the flavors settle better and it actually slices).
2. Store leftovers in the fridge. It holds up for about three days, but good luck making it last that long.
3. For reheating, skip the microwave. Pop it in the oven at 350 degrees for 10 minutes so the crust stays crispy.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use store-bought tomatoes out of season?

Sure, but if you can find local, in-season tomatoes, it’ll taste a million times better.

Do I really have to salt and drain the tomatoes first?

Yep, unless you want tomato soup in a crust (which… don’t even).

Can I make it without mayo?

You could, but that’s the soul of this pie. Some folks use Greek yogurt as a swap, but it’s not quite the same.

Is this dish vegetarian?

It totally is! Just check your pie crust for the usual sneaky ingredients, but otherwise you’re good.

Can I freeze tomato pie?

Eh, I wouldn’t. The tomatoes go kinda mushy. Best to eat it fresh, or the day after at the latest.

Wrapping It Up: Why Tomato Pie Is True Southern Gold

There you have it. Southern tomato pie is humble, unfancy, and it’ll blow any pizza out the water if you do it right. If you want to wow your family without breaking a sweat, this is your golden ticket. Don’t just take my word for it—check out the Southern Living guide, or the heaps of five-star tomato pie love online. Trust me—once this hits your table, you’ll wonder why you waited so long to try it.

 

Print