How to Cook the Best Steak (Pan-Seared Steak)

Pan-Seared Steak cravings hit hard, right? You want steakhouse vibes but your kitchen’s right there… and, let’s be real, restaurants ain’t exactly budget-friendly these days. Maybe you’ve tried to cook steak before and it turned out—well, let’s call it “leathery sadness.” I’ve been there. My first Pan-Seared Steak was sort of a disaster. Then I found a few tricks to get it juicy, perfectly crisped, all that good stuff. If you already love steak upgrades (have you tried this best cheesesteak tortellini recipe easy? So worth it), you’re in for a treat. Let’s get cracking!

The BEST Pan-Seared Steak

Let’s not sugarcoat it: this is the everyday hero of steak recipes. Not “everyday” as in bland—more like, with the right attitude and a heavy pan, anyone can make a steak taste five-star at home. My uncle swears by salted butter and a screaming hot cast iron. (He’s not wrong.)

What’s so magical? For starters, pan-searing gets the outside really crisp. Not crust like on bread, but flavor-packed, brown and a teeny bit crunchy. The inside stays melt-in-your-mouth tender once you nail the timing.

I’ll never forget one friend saying, “This is better than a fancy steakhouse. How?” It’s honestly simple: good beef, high heat, don’t mess with it too much. Salt, pepper, that’s mostly it. Rest the steak before slicing. If your last one was chewy—try again, don’t let it haunt your kitchen dreams.

How to Pan Sear Steaks

First thing: bring the steak to room temp. I used to skip this—bad move. Cold meat doesn’t cook evenly. Sprinkle way more salt than seems normal. Trust me.

Get your pan really hot first. Flick a drop of water—if it jumps and sizzles, that’s right. Add oil (something high-smoke like canola works), put the steak in, and don’t touch it for a couple minutes. Let it do its thing. Sear both sides till a brown crust forms.

Flip once. Resist the urge to poke. Near the end, throw in a knob of butter and maybe some smashed garlic or thyme for a little chef-y flair. Baste the steak—just tilt the pan, spoon the melted butter over. Makes a crazy difference in taste.

When it feels sorta springy but not stiff (rare is softest, well-done feels firmish), pull it off. Rest it on a plate for 5-7 minutes or… okay, three if you’re starving. And by the way, if you want some fun sides, try this garlic butter steak bites recipe with it.

Steak Doneness Temperature Chart

It can be confusing, honestly. Juicy or chewy—how do folks know when it’s right? I used to do the “poke test,” but the meat thermometer is my BFF now. Here’s what you need:

Rare: 120-125°F. Super soft, bright red inside
Medium Rare: 130-135°F. Softish, a little red, mostly pink (the classic)
Medium: 140-145°F. Kind of firm, mostly pink
Medium Well: 150-155°F. Almost no pink, still juicy, a little chewy
Well Done: 160°F and up. All brown, pretty darn firm

The steak keeps cooking a bit while it sits (“carryover cooking”—sounds so official). Shoot for a few degrees under your goal temp, because it’ll reach perfection as it rests.

I used to be scared to undercook steak, but once I trusted my thermometer, every steak came out crazy good. My family asks for seconds now!

Pro Tips for the Best Steak

Alright—if you want that five-star taste at home, check these out:

• Dry the steak with paper towels before you start. Wet steak won’t brown properly.
• Use a heavy cast iron pan or stainless steel. Nonstick doesn’t get hot enough (and, weirdly, sticks).
• Spoon those pan juices over your steak while it finishes, especially if you tossed in aromatics (garlic or rosemary).
• Let it rest after cooking! Seriously, this is the difference between good Pan-Seared Steak and a dry letdown.

My mom always says: don’t rush steak or you’ll regret it. Hurrying makes for so many sad dinners. Take those extra few minutes—worth it.

The Best Cut of Steak to Use For This Method

Here’s the thing: not all steaks behave the same in a pan. Skip the super lean ones like eye of round—too tough. You want some fat marbling for flavor and juiciness.

Ribeye is my #1. It’s the king, no question. New York strip is almost as good. Filet mignon if you feel fancy but it’s less flavorful (sorry, it just is). Sirloin is cheaper, works well, not as buttery but still tasty if you treat it right.

Avoid thin steaks—they overcook mega fast. Go for at least an inch thick. Thicker = more time to get crispy outside, juicy inside. Try different cuts when you can—see what your crew likes best. My little brother will take a NY strip over anything, every time.

Serving Suggestions

Okay, so you’ve got your Pan-Seared Steak, perfectly cooked… now what goes with?

• Crispy roasted potatoes—always in style, right?
• Simple mixed greens salad if you need something light
• Sautéed mushrooms and onions, classic steakhouse move
• Or, level up and try steak and cheese quesadillas recipe easy for a change!

Don’t forget a splash of pan juices over everything. Steak night feels legit with the extras.

Common Questions

Q: How long should I cook each side?
A: Depends on thickness, but for a one-inch steak, about 2-3 minutes per side for medium rare does it.

Q: Can I use olive oil?
A: You can, but it smokes faster. I go for canola or avocado oil because my smoke alarm is dramatic.

Q: Should I let the steak rest after cooking?
A: Yes! Five minutes, minimum. If you skip, all the juices rush out.

Q: Can I pan-sear a frozen steak?
A: I tried it once. Messy and uneven. If desperate, sure, but it’s really best to thaw first.

Q: What if I don’t have a thermometer?
A: Use the “feel test,” but, to be honest, after I bought a cheap digital thermometer, my steaks never went wrong again.

Steak Night, Sorted

Making Pan-Seared Steak at home is kinda empowering. Once you learn the basics, you’ll never settle for boring steak again. Just remember to get your pan hot, don’t mess with the steak too much, and let that steak rest. Craving more ideas? Don’t miss checking out Pan Seared Steak Recipe (Steakhouse Quality!) – NatashasKitchen … for more inspiration, and if you get ambitious, peek at America’s Test Kitchen’s pan-seared steak guide for some next-level tricks. Give it a spin tonight—it’ll blow your mind how good it is. Seriously, if you want to round out dinner with something salad-y, their easy grilled balsamic steak salad recipe is also a slam dunk.

📌 Save This Recipe for Later – Pin It Now on Pinterest!

Love this recipe? Don’t lose it—pin it to your favorite board on Pinterest now and have it ready when hunger hits! 📌😋

Print