Sizzling Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter Delight

Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter. Yep, the name alone is a mouthful, but trust me—this one’s special. Ever battled with steak at home—dry edges, tough centers, and that sad little pool of gray drippings instead of a sizzling, juicy masterpiece? I’ve been right there with ya, cussing at the skillet. That’s why buttery, flavor-packed basting techniques like this are game changers. Oh, and if you’re feeling extra steak-happy, give these garlic butter steak bites a try too—they’re like little nuggets of joy.

Temperature is key to butter basting a steak

Okay, hear me out. You can’t just whack a steak onto a skillet and blast the heat to “lava” levels. Nope. For Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter, you need finesse and patience. Start by letting your steak sit out—room temperature is its happy spot. That way, you don’t shock it ice cold to sizzling hot. You want an even cook inside and out.

Now, about that heat? Medium-high is your hero. Too hot, the outside burns before the inside even thinks about catching up. Too cool, and your steak just kinda sweats—nobody wants that. Once you get your sear, keep a close watch with a thermometer (I used to skip this and regretted it every time). Aiming for about 130-135°F for medium-rare gives you pink, juicy bites every forkful. Oh, and resting your steak might feel like the hardest two minutes of your life, but the flavor payoff is wild. Okay, maybe that’s dramatic, but I stand by it.

Perfect butter basted steak is flipped often, not once

Let’s talk flipping. I’ll be honest, I used to believe you should only flip a steak once—like it was some sacred cow (sorry, couldn’t help it). Turns out, the pros (and home cooks who like five-star results) flip their steaks a LOT. Don’t just chuck it in the pan and walk off. Flip every thirty seconds to a minute. This helps the Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter cook up evenly. Both sides get steady love, and your outside gets that golden, delicious crust without overcooking the middle. If I’m hungry and impatient (which, let’s face it, is all the time), this technique has saved both my steak and my mood.

Don’t worry if you drop a piece of thyme in the pan or if that butter goes wild—just keep flipping. The basting butter brings even more flavor, so let it soak in with each turn. Your taste buds will notice, promise.

Add your butter last to avoid burning

Butter’s delicious, but it’s also a diva. If you toss it in too soon, it turns brown (or worse, black) before your steak’s even halfway done. I always, always wait until the last few minutes to add my butter to the Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter. That way, you get all those nutty, aromatic flavors swirling around your steak and none of the bitter burnt bits.

Here’s my trick—once both sides of your steak are nicely seared, slide in your butter, bay leaf, and fresh thyme. Tilt the pan a little and start spooning that melted, herby goodness over the top. It smells like heaven on a Sunday morning. Plus, it leaves your steak extra juicy. DO NOT burn that butter; it’s the secret sauce, so protect it with your life (okay, not literally, but you get me).

Essential equipment for butter basted steak

You don’t need a fancy setup, but a couple of solid tools make all the difference:

• Heavy skillet or cast iron: These hold heat better and give you an awesome crust. Seriously, that sizzle? Music to my ears.
• Tongs: Not a fork, not a spatula. Tongs let you flip and move the steak without poking holes or making a mess.
• Meat thermometer: I used to wing it and guess doneness by poking the steak, but too many ruined dinners taught me better. Thermometer = confidence.
• Spoon: A plain spoon is your basting friend. Use it to scoop up all that butter, bay, and thyme glory and let the steak have a bath.

Get these out before you even pull the steak from the fridge. Saves you a mad scramble mid-cook.

Chef Notes + Tips

Okay, so this isn’t some stiff chef-y kitchen. But I’ve messed up plenty, and here’s what I tell all my steak-loving friends: buy good meat, but don’t over-complicate things. Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter just wants a hot pan, room-temperature steak, and a watchful eye. Don’t wander off to check your phone or you’ll regret it.

Also, let your steak rest—seriously, don’t skip that. All those tasty juices you worked so hard for? They need a moment to settle, otherwise, you’re mopping them off your plate with a napkin.

And one more thing—don’t be shy with salt. I’m not saying go full salt-bae, but season both sides like you mean it.

“I tried this butter basting trick on a random Sunday and holy wow! My family actually thought we ordered steakhouse delivery. Never going back to boring pan-seared steak.” — Jamie from Akron, OH

Common Questions

Can I use dried herbs instead of fresh?
Absolutely—just use a bit less since dried herbs are way punchier than fresh. Still tasty!

How do I keep my butter from burning?
Keep your heat on medium and add the butter once the steak is almost cooked through. Stir, swirl, and don’t walk away.

What oil works best for the initial sear?
Use a high-heat oil, like canola or avocado, before you add butter. Olive oil can burn fast—save it for salads.

Is a meat thermometer really necessary?
I was stubborn too. But unless you can see inside your steak with X-ray vision, a thermometer just makes it foolproof.

How thick should my steak be?
At least 1.5 inches thick for a Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter. Thin ones dry out before they soak up that flavor.

Time to Grab Your Skillet and Go!

That’s pretty much my whole playbook for knocking the socks off anyone (or just yourself) with a killer Delmonico Steak with Bay and Thyme Butter. If you want to mix things up for steak night, you could also check out these steak and cheese quesadillas for a completely different take. When it comes to the herb debate, the folks at Rosemary or thyme? : r/steak have a lot to say—it never hurts to see what folks love in the comments.

Just remember, trust your senses, don’t skimp on that sizzling butter, and give this a whirl. Seriously, try it tonight. The bay and thyme combo will blow your mind.

📌 Save This Recipe for Later – Pin It Now on Pinterest!

Love this recipe? Don’t lose it—pin it to your favorite board on Pinterest now and have it ready when hunger hits! 📌😋

Print